The Watchmen

We greet the news that AI could extinguish us with a glazed indifference. What is the way out of this nihilism? | Brigid Delaney

Guardian - Artificial Intelligence · September 14, 2026
We greet the news that AI could extinguish us with a glazed indifference. What is the way out of this nihilism? | Brigid Delaney
Source:Guardian - Artificial Intelligence

Summary

The article argues that fear of artificial intelligence, climate pressures, economic instability, and other overlapping crises have produced widespread pessimism and emotional numbness. It begins with an anecdote about a father who briefly regretted having children after hearing claims that AI could cause human extinction within 10 years. The author suggests that people increasingly view education, careers, home ownership, retirement, and family life through the possibility that AI will eliminate jobs, undermine human purpose, or destabilize society. The article also raises concerns about AI’s energy and water consumption, its growing role in workplaces and emotional support, and its potential effect on critical thinking and collective action. These concerns are attributed generally to recent news and public discussion rather than documented in detail. The proposed response is not to abandon technology entirely, but to “wake up,” resist fatalism, and return to principles of human flourishing. The author defines flourishing as independent thought, direct human relationships, care for the natural world, and technology used within appropriate limits. The conclusion calls for active civic and cultural resistance to AI applications believed to threaten those goods.

Watchmen Signals

Biblical Prophecy
No

Biblical Context

The article does not present a specifically biblical question, and it does not establish that AI fulfills biblical prophecy. A limited thematic connection exists with biblical teaching about human responsibility, wisdom, relationships, and care for creation. Genesis presents humanity as having responsibility to cultivate and keep the created world, which broadly relates to the article’s concern about technology’s environmental effects. Ecclesiastes emphasizes the value of mutual support and shared life, paralleling the article’s preference for human-to-human relationships over dependence on machines. These are broad principles rather than direct statements about artificial intelligence. Scripture does not provide a basis for concluding from this article that AI is the prophesied end-times mechanism or that human extinction is imminent.

Biblical Sources

Scripture references supporting the biblical context above.

The passage highlights the practical value of companionship and mutual support, thematically relating to the article’s argument that human flourishing depends on real human relationships rather than excessive reliance on machines.

God places the man in the garden to work it and keep it, providing a broad biblical basis for responsible care of the natural world, an issue raised by the article’s concerns about AI’s environmental costs.

Comments

No comments yet.

Sign in to join the conversation.

Sign In
Read original article