Viewpoint: “Positive eugenics”: Reviving a movement reviled and condemned for a century

The Watchmen's Summary
Author Jan Grue argues that consumer genetic screening represents a modern form of “liberal eugenics,” replacing state coercion with parental choice while still ranking human traits. He points to Nucleus Genomics advertisements promoting IVF screening for up to 20 embryos and claims about height and intelligence, though those heritability figures do not reliably predict an individual child’s traits. Grue also cites prenatal screening practices, including Denmark’s reported termination rate after Down syndrome diagnoses, and urges societies to improve conditions for disabled people rather than pursue an idealized “best” human.
Biblical Context
Human worth is not assigned by intelligence, health, appearance, productivity, or genetic desirability. Genesis 1:27 grounds the dignity of every human being in bearing God's image, which challenges the idea that a commercially preferred trait profile defines a “best baby.” The concern that selecting desirable characteristics may devalue people who lack them also connects with James 2:1-4, where believers are warned against judging people by visible status and treating some as more worthy than others. The passage does not address IVF or embryo testing, but its rejection of status-based favoritism is relevant to social attitudes toward disability and human difference. Paul's description of the church in 1 Corinthians 12:22-26 is especially pertinent to the treatment of vulnerable or apparently weaker people. He teaches that members who seem weaker are indispensable and that the body should give greater honor to those lacking honor. This supports the principle that dependence or disability does not make a person less valuable. These passages provide ethical principles rather than a direct biblical ruling on embryo screening, modern genetics, or the specific practices described in the essay.
Watchmen Signals
Commercial embryo selection invites parents to rank traits such as intelligence, appearance, health, and disability, while the essay questions whether people who do not fit those preferences will be valued equally. Scripture grounds human worth in bearing God's image and rejects favoritism based on perceived status, although it does not directly address IVF, embryo testing, or modern genetic counseling.
No specific biblical prophecy describes commercial embryo screening, consumer eugenics, or changing views of disability. The development raises serious questions about human dignity and social discrimination, but those ethical concerns should not be presented as evidence that a particular prophecy is being fulfilled.
The piece is a reflective essay about an ongoing ethical debate and previously established reproductive technologies, not a sudden policy change, medical breakthrough, or rapidly developing crisis requiring immediate notification.
Biblical Sources
Scripture references supporting the biblical context above.
Paul teaches that members who appear weaker are indispensable and deserve special honor, offering a direct biblical principle against treating disability or dependence as evidence of lesser human worth.
Human beings are created in God's image, grounding human dignity in God's act of creation rather than in intelligence, health, appearance, or productivity.
James condemns favoritism based on outward status. Although the passage does not concern genetic screening, its rejection of ranking people by perceived superiority applies to the social devaluation of disability or other traits.
Comments
No comments yet.
Sign in to join the conversation.
Sign InStay Informed. Grow in Biblical Understanding.
Explore important news from around the world through the context of God's Word. Create your FREE Watchmen account to discover more news analysis, Biblical Insights, and Scripture-based perspectives.
Create Your FREE AccountFree to join. No credit card required.